Should convert 'k' and 't' sounds to 'g' and 'd' sounds when they follow 's' in a word for pronunciation? Is there Delhi quota in Lady Hardinge Medical College? As Hermione says in book 7: "Look, if I picked up a sword right now, Ron, and ran you through with it, I wouldn't damage your soul at all." @marcellothearcane harry might have died from his skull being crushed if the basilisk bit his head. Connect and share knowledge within a single location that is structured and easy to search. I established early in the book, Hermione says that you destroy a Horcrux by using something so powerful that there's no remedy. Cookie Notice Harry Potter fans have wondered why the horcrux in Harry Potter wasn't killed by the basilisk's poison, and there's a good explanation for that. By clicking Accept All, you consent to the use of ALL the cookies. This happened after Voldemort attempted, and failed, to use the killing curse on him when he was just a baby. At the time, the extent of the diary's true nature was not revealed, as Harry was led to believe Tom Riddle was a memory strengthened by Ginny feeding her emotions to him. Why did the Basilisk fang destroy the diary? Like the locket, Helga Hufflepuff's cup is also the family heirloom of a founding member of Hogwarts. She is beheaded by Neville Longbottom with the Sword of Gryffindor in both the book and the film. The 'Love Protection' only covers Harry and not the Horcrux. and our It does not store any personal data. In the Summer of 1996, when Dumbledore found the ring under the rotting floorboards of the Gaunt shack, he saw it immediately as the Hallow that he had desired for so many years, the Resurrection Stone. Lockhart, who had no plans to actually fight the Basilisk, attacked the students with Ron's own broken wand, which backfired on him, and wiped his memory. Scan this QR code to download the app now. A great answer! As it was pointed out to me in Why Didn't the Basilisk Bite in Book Two Destroy the Horcrux, when Harry stabbed the diary Horcrux with the Basilisk fang, the diary wasn't destroyed instantaneously; there could have been time for Fawkes to cry onto the stab "wound". Harry Potter Wiki is a FANDOM Movies Community. Harry managed to destroy the Horcrux with venom from the fang of a Basilisk. [3], Ginny Weasley furtively writing in the diary, Some time during the First Wizarding War, Lord Voldemort entrusted the diary to Death Eater, Lucius Malfoy. @Slytherincess - "perhaps she would have died a slow death" - quite likely. The cookie is used to store the user consent for the cookies in the category "Other. :). You also have the option to opt-out of these cookies. Unless the basilisk was gentle? As the title asks, why didn't the basilisk bite received in the Chamber of Secrets destroy the Horcrux inside the bitten person? [15] She feared that Riddle would tell Harry about her feelings toward him, and shortly thereafter went missing. 1 Why did the Basilisk fang destroy the diary? JKR: Well, youve got- if his body had been irreparably destroyed. On the evening of 29 May 1993, Harry returned to the girls' lavatory and successfully discovered and opened the Chamber of Secrets. Dumbledore ultimately destroyed the ring with the sword of Godric Gryffindor, but not without suffering the consequences. [1][2], The venom's potency was apparently extremely long-lasting, as Hermione Granger was able to use the venom from the fang of a Basilisk that was dead for nearly five years. This cookie is set by GDPR Cookie Consent plugin. Just typing your deepest thoughts into the ether and getting answers back, and you don't know who is answering you. Also in the same game, Ginny Weasley, after the death of the basilisk, played with the book (as it was tied to Riddle's soul in a physical sense which allowed her to fling Riddle himself around in accordance to its movements), though she ignored Harry by hitting him in the ribs as she was too into fiddling around with it. Why didn't Dumbledore think of using a basilisk fang to destroy the horcruxes? In the life of every great fandom, there come times when people end up finding loopholes or inconsistencies in the plot and seek answers. In the film adaptation, Harry destroyed the diary with the fang. +1, I'd always taken the "heart of the book" comment to mean either breaking the spine, or the fang being sharp enough to pierce every page. Copyright 2023 Endgame360 Inc. All Rights Reserved. Interestingly, the book could be compared to, In a deleted scene from the film adaptation of. As a result of that act, a curse nearly killed him. [1], Later, Ginny, having seen the diary amongst Harry's books, stole the diary from among Harry's room in the Gryffindor Boys' Dormitory. Although the destruction of the ring occurred off-page, Dumbledore used the Sword of Gryffindor to destroy it, so presumably, like the locket, it was gone right away. Science Fiction & Fantasy Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for science fiction and fantasy enthusiasts. Winstanley's Bookstore & Stationers, Vauxhall Road, London[1] As fans learn over the course of the series, Voldemort found a way to make himself virtually immortal. Who was killed to make Nagini a Horcrux (Frank Bryce or Bertha Jorkins)? Even as he dropped the fang and watched his own blood soaking his robes, his vision went foggy. "on the night Lord Voldemort tried to kill him, when Lily cast her own life between them as a shield, the Killing Curse rebounded on Lord Voldemort, and a fragment of Lord Voldemort's soul was blasted apart from the whole, and latched itself onto the only living soul left As Dumbledore puts it in Deathly Hallows. the answer: jk Rowling recently explained this- the object holding the horcrux has to be totally destroyed. But I've since thought "Well it's very similar." It has to be something so destructive that the Horcrux cant repair itself. The best answers are voted up and rise to the top, Not the answer you're looking for? J. K. Rowling has also stated: "Now, the diary to me is a very scary object, a really, really frightening object. My only niggle with your answer is that I don't consider the movies to be canon proper. [17], The diary showing Harry Potter a memory from fifty years ago. When Harry was stabbed by a basilisk in the Chamber of Secrets, since he was a Horcrux, shouldn't it have been destroyed then? [12][2], Harry Potter entering the Chamber of Secrets. Harry stabbed the Basilisk through the roof of its mouth, but was bitten in the process. Riddle". (Since my books are still on loan and not being returned when they should, I don't have access to check. Returning to the horcrux element of the discussion, it's possible that when a soul is bound to a conscious being, it share's that being's "vessel", which is the brain. T. M. Riddle's Diary So before he could be destroyed without repair, which is what is necessary to destroy a horcrux, he was mended. For more information, please see our Moreover, the fact that the fang was struck "through the heart" of the book may be significant - it's possible that simply ripping one page with a fang or scratching a corner would have done some damage but not destroyed the Horcrux outright. She said, A Horcrux can only be destroyed if its container is damaged beyond repair. Necessary cookies are absolutely essential for the website to function properly. A Basilisk fang. He was considered a genius, he knew there was a dead basilisk in the chamber of secrets at Hogwarts and that Harry destroyed Tom Riddle's diary with its fang but instead of doing it the simple way, he kept thinking of other ways. Yes, I know Fawkes quite quickly healed the bite wound with his phoenix tears, but when Harry used the basilisk fang to destroy Tom Riddle's diary the destruction of that Horcrux was immediate. It was here that he discovered the water-logged diary, which Ginny had discarded when she suspected that it was she who had petrified the Muggle-borns and finally realised that the diary was the cause. The plan was to use the diary to reopen the Chamber, but Voldemort fell before that plan came to fruition, although Voldemort never told Lucius that the diary contained a fragment of his soul, instead simply making it appear to be cleverly charmed. Question 328 comments (SU: Yeah) He has to die to get rid of that piece of soul. 2023 Viacom International Inc. All Rights Reserved. How come when Harry gets bitten by the Basilisk in Chamber of Secrets that doesn't destroy the Horcrux in him? We just aren't told this part because it is in "the other world" one enters after death. I was. But the film sees Harry stab the Diadem with a basilisk fang before tossing it into the Fiendfyre. Not only does it destroy the one inside Tom Riddle's diary, but Ron and Hermione also use one of the fangs to destroy Helga Hufflepuff's cup. [8] She soon learned how to use the diary to communicate with Tom Riddle, though she was unaware that he was Lord Voldemort, or if he was even real. This manipulative little book, the temptation particularly for a young girl to pour out her heart to a diary, which is never something I was prone to, but my sister was. She was forced to paint a threat against her life on the walls of a hallway and sealed herself inside the Chamber. Throughout the books and films, it became Harry Potters job to find and destroy the Horcruxes so that he could stop Voldemort once and for all. Answer (1 of 3): Actually if you observe carefully, the liquid that expunges out of the diary after Harry stabbed it is ink. Malfoy still possessed the diary and, in 1992, he planted it on Ginny Weasley, hoping to kill three birds with one stone by sabotaging Ginny's father, purge the school of Muggle-borns, and eliminate an incriminating Dark artefact.[4]. [Source], T. M. Riddle's Diary[6] was a simple blank diary belonging to Tom Riddle, who also transformed it into a Horcrux in 1943, during Riddle's sixth year at Hogwarts School of Witchcraft and Wizardry. This cookie is set by GDPR Cookie Consent plugin. So we now that even if Harry had died his soul remained there. We know the soul piece was killed by a Killing Curse, which neither killed Harry or irreparably destroyed his body - but he was actually killed somewhat. When Ron hit the locket with the Sword of Gryffindor, it was destroyed immediately. In the books, it is unintentionally destroyed by Vincent Crabbe in a "Fiendfyre." But the film sees Harry stab the Diadem with a basilisk fang before tossing it into the Fiendfyre. Whatever the circumstances were, she eventually becomes Lord Voldemort's "pet," and she is the only other living creature besides Harry that Voldemort made into a Horcrux. Harrys horcrux was eventually destroyed in the final book, but could it have been killed years before? After Myrtle's death, Albus Dumbledore, then Professor of Transfiguration, began suspecting Riddle. [3], The inside cover and front page of the diary, showing the faint inscription "T.M. Next: Harry Potter Theory: Dumbledore Is Death In The Deathly Hallows, one of the steps in the making of a horcrux, Harry Potter: Everyone Voldemort Killed To Make Horcruxes (& Why), Harry Potter Theory: Dumbledore Is Death In The Deathly Hallows. Learn more about Stack Overflow the company, and our products. [1] He imbued the diary with other powers, so that the Chamber could be opened again in the future. May 29, 1993: Harry Potter stabs a basilisk fang into Tom Riddles diary inside the Chamber of Secrets unknowingly destroying his first Horcrux. Many people in the replies to this post provided the same explanation. Voldemort's seven Horcruxes were a crucial plot point of the Harry Potter movies. and to me they are a really nice visual representation of what JKR's universe might look like when brought to life. Vinyl, The Harry Potter Wiki has 77 images related to, *Disclosure: Some of the links above are affiliate links, meaning, at no additional cost to you, Fandom will earn a commission if you click through and make a purchase. As this diary contained Riddle's soul, it also housed his magical powers. We know that Harry is a very complicated kind of horcrux. However, the Dark Lord was relying too much on Malfoy's fear of him, but Malfoy believed him to be dead. In reality, the matter was more complicated, as Dumbledore would reveal in Harry Potter and the Half-Blood Prince that the diary was just one of seven Horcruxes. Incidentally it does not seem to be common knowledge what comes after death, though several characters have had insight into it (the priori incantatem incident, Harry's interaction with the Veil in the Department of Mysteries) and it seems that consciousness persists after death in the HP world, but that it is apparently freed from the body for a destination unknown. Can I trust my bikes frame after I was hit by a car if there's no visible cracking? [10] She did all this while in a sort of trance, never knowing what she had done. His body was starting to get destroyed, but as with the book, it was a process, made of course much lengthier due to the fact that the bite was in his hand, and damage was spreading slowly and steadily. It doesnt have to be a Basilisk fang. [1][2] When Harry's ink bottles shattered and drenched all of his other textbooks, the diary alone remained dry and unmarked. What did Lucius Malfoy know about the diary? Harry uses the same fang to destroy Tom Riddle's diary, killing the memory preserved in it. The answer is simple: He didn't actually die. Her emotional vulnerability allowed the fragment of Voldemort's soul within the diary to gain partial control of her mind. I'm definitely fallible when it comes to HP; there's still so much to learn! Is there a grammatical term to describe this usage of "may be"? ", In the book, Harry Potter only destroyed the diary with the Basilisk fang after he was healed by Fawkes. Made Speculation ahead; the reason WHY in the case of an animal, death is required rather than just damage, is very likely due to the Horcrux not being bonded to the entire body (and thus vulnerable to damage at any point), but to the brain. All the answers above use well grounded information that are not based on "Harry being different" whatsoever. It is an heirloom of the Slytherin family, having been owned by Salazar Slytherin, of whom Voldemort is a direct descendant. Voldemort tried killing Harry in the forest with the Elder Wand. And we know from Dumbledore, also in 7, that "a fragment of Voldemort's soul was blasted apart from the whole, and latched itself onto the only living soul left in that collapsing building." Archived post. Spoilers will be present within the article. This is why Harry stabbing Toms diary instantly destroys it in Harry Potter And The Chamber Of Secrets. Readers around the world were introduced to the Wizarding World in 1997 with Harry Potter and the Philosophers Stone, the first in what would become a successful book series with a total of seven novels. Harry was exceptionally fortunate in that he had Fawkes. Dumbledore knew basilisk fangs would be supremely useful to Harry. But what were those items, and how were they destroyed? [1], Tom Riddle using Myrtle Warren's death to create his diary Horcrux, When Tom Marvolo Riddle was in his fifth year at Hogwarts, he achieved his goal of locating Salazar Slytherin's Chamber of Secrets and used his ability to speak Parseltongue to open it. Ginny was forced not only to paint terrifying threats in the school corridors,[9] but she released the Basilisk within the Chamber as well. Can someone hack my PC through online games? It was the first Horcrux he ever made and was used as a weapon. [1][2], The basilisk venom had burned a sizzling hole right through it.T. @llamaofthelab The Horcrux-receptacle has to be destroyed BEYOND REPAIR, so Harry would need to have DIED. We also use third-party cookies that help us analyze and understand how you use this website. The diadem seems to have been destroyed by Fiendfyre immediately as well, as when Harry examined it outside the Room of Requirement it was already leaking a blood-like substance, and then it cracked in half. It's less obvious but can be fairly clearly inferred from CoS book: Harry seized the basilisk fang on the floor next to him and plunged it straight into the heart of the book. rev2023.6.2.43474. Had Fawkes not arrived to help Harry, he would have died, along with the piece of Voldemorts soul hidden within him. At least some content in this article is derived from information featured in Harry Potter: Puzzles & Spells. I have been told that Harry wasn't a normal Horcrux, as he wasn't made intentionaly, so as he is not a normal Horcrux, the destruction of the Horcrux inside would be different. And once Riddle gains possession of the item, he turns it into a Horcrux and hides it in the Room of Requirements. [1], After being healed, Harry took the fang and stabbed Riddle's diary, destroying that Horcrux beyond magical repair. Although the ring was destroyed before the events of Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows, the Resurrection Stone survived, to be discovered later by Harry inside the golden snitch. Harry indeed had to die in order to have the horcrux in him destroyed, so if Fawkes hadnt arrived to help, the piece of Voldemorts soul living in Harry would have been killed by the basilisks poison at that moment. Now what if the basilisk had bitten the scar? These cookies track visitors across websites and collect information to provide customized ads. While it is no secret that, throughout the series, Harry is subconsciously linked to Voldemort, the reason is not revealed until the last act of Deathly Hallows. Why didn't the basilisk bite in Chamber of Secrets destroy the Horcrux? In the books, it is unintentionally destroyed by Vincent Crabbe in a "Fiendfyre." [2], Harry destroying the diary with a Basilisk fang. Following this logic, if Harry had died from the Basilisk bite, then the Horcrux would have been destroyed (but that didn't happen). If you don't think it should have posted here you can always DV. All rights reserved. Out of these, the cookies that are categorized as necessary are stored on your browser as they are essential for the working of basic functionalities of the website. As you can see, it was a process of destruction, not something instantaneous. Because Lucius was unaware that the diary was actually a container for his master's soul fragment, he treated it with such light-handedness. Is there a faster algorithm for max(ctz(x), ctz(y))? Couldn't he just ask Harry to open the chamber and go get the fang? Would sending audio fragments over a phone call be considered a form of cryptology? After being healed, Harry took the fang and stabbed Riddle's diary, destroying that Horcrux beyond magical repair. Seriously, did the bite kill Harry or just come close to killing him? White-hot pain was spreading slowly and steadily from the wound. (JN: Yeah) That was stated right in the beginning with the Horcrux, the receptacle has got to be destroyed. He tethered you to life while he lives! When Voldemort used Harrys blood to rebuild his body during the Triwizard Tournament, Lily Potters love and sacrifice that originally saved Harry as a baby became part of Voldemort. Thats one Harry Potter mystery solved! Functional cookies help to perform certain functionalities like sharing the content of the website on social media platforms, collect feedbacks, and other third-party features. The cookies is used to store the user consent for the cookies in the category "Necessary". Harry then took one of the Basilisk's fangs and stabbed the diary with it. The Harry Potter film series expanded this universes fanbase, and also left a bunch of questions and a couple of plot holes that havent been answered yet, even though Rowling has addressed some of them in interviews, entries in Wizarding World (formerly Pottermore), or random Q&A sessions on Twitter. As it turns out, when Fawkes healed Harrys arm, he also healed the Horcrux that Harry houses. [2] Riddle would later use this murder to infuse the journal with a piece of his soul, and transformed it into his first Horcrux. J.K. Rowlings Harry Potter book series has become a worldwide phenomenon. [2] This diary served as proof that Lord Voldemort was indeed using Horcruxes. When the Weasleys and Harry left to King's Cross Station, Ginny accidentally left the diary behind at the Burrow. Performance cookies are used to understand and analyze the key performance indexes of the website which helps in delivering a better user experience for the visitors. Because Harry had stabbed the Basilisk with the sword, it was imbued with Basilisk venom and was therefore able to destroy Horcruxes and poison opponents that it cut through as well. The closer a writer became to the memory of Tom Riddle emotionally, the more power the diary would acquire over him or her. How do you identify neurotypical disorders? 1 NiceDrewishFella Hufflepuff 1 yr. ago She didn't literally pour her soul into the diary, nor did he consume it. This Horcrux was destroyed by Lord Voldemort himself. Welcome to r/HarryPotter, the place where fans from around the world can meet and discuss everything in the Harry Potter universe! As it turns out, Fawkes not only saved Harry but also the part of Voldemorts soul living in him. These come together with something Hermione says in Deathly Hallows: "Look, if I picked up a sword right now, Ron, and ran you through with it, I wouldn't damage your soul at all.whatever happens to your body, your soul will survive, untouched," said Hermione. J.K. Rowling: The Horcrux-receptacle has to be destroyed BEYOND REPAIR, so Harry would need to have DIED. Could he actually have died? Explained: Why Harry Potter Survives Basilisks Fang Despite it Being A Horcrux. As a Horcrux, the diary allowed a writer to communicate with the memory of the sixteen-year-old Tom Riddle, merely through writing on the journal's blank pages. Could the Sword of Gryffindor have destroyed a horcrux before it absorbed the Basilisk Venom. 2 On what date did Harry destroy Riddles diary with a Basilisk fang? Otherwise, the fact that the diary was a common artefact made it very ironic to be considered valuable in Voldemort's eyes, especially when it was manufactured by his hated enemies: Muggles. Given this, I'd have to agree with Sydenam (and others using the same general idea) whole-heartedly. Although it is unclear how that happened, by the time of the Harry Potter series, the change was permanent. Harry heard strange voices in the walls of Hogwarts, which exhorted the urge to kill. Basilisk is born by chicken egg hatched by toad. The best illustration of that is in the movie, when the diary needs to be stabbed several times by the Basilisk fang in order to completely destroy the soul fragment manifesting itself as Riddle. Prior to stabbing the diary, the basilisk bit Harrys forearm. It not only served as one of Voldemort's Horcruxes, but it also contained the Resurrection Stone. Why is it bonded with the brain? Harry Potter Wiki is a FANDOM Movies Community. Rowena Ravenclaw possessed the item, which could make its wearer smarter, before it was stolen by her own daughter, Helena. Which of the following is an alternative to a fixed price revenue model? He didn't die from the basilisk because it would still take a moment for the venom to reach his heart, and the horcrux was in his soul. A post shared by Harry Potter Film (@harrypotterfilm). While its origins were explored in greater detail in the novel, the general idea of how Tom Riddle retrieved the Diadem remains mostly the same in the film. . Well, I always thought that Harry survived in the forest because he was having all the three deathly hallows with him at that time. There have been innumerable debates and questions surrounding the stories and characters in the Harry Potter series. The destruction of the Diadem was another element that differed from book to film. Related: Harry Potter: Everyone Voldemort Killed To Make Horcruxes (& Why). Harry was healed by Fawkes. RELATED: How the Knight Bus Found Harry Potter. A Basilisk's fang is one of the few things that can destroy a Horcrux. The curse weakened Dumbledore to a noticeable degree. While the events surrounding Nagini's demise differ from the source material, mostly in the sense of when it occurs, the way in which she dies is largely the same. So, in conclusion, the reason the last (Harry) Horcrux was not destroyed from Basilisk bite was because the Phoenix tears stopped the venom spread and healed the damage before the Horcrux vessel (Harry) was completely destroyed. CEO Update: Paving the road forward with AI and community at the center, Building a safer community: Announcing our new Code of Conduct, AI/ML Tool examples part 3 - Title-Drafting Assistant, We are graduating the updated button styling for vote arrows. Kristen is a freelance writer for CBR. Concealing his true nature as a Horcrux, Riddle claimed to be a memory of his younger self, and revealed the truth of his identity and plans to Harry and unleashed the Basilisk. Read on to find out why the Horcrux remained in Harry, despite being bit by the basilisk. Heres the question posed by one Redditor: JK Rowling has repeatedly answered this question on social media platforms. In Harry Potter and the Chamber of Secrets, Harry finds Ginny Weasley inside the Chamber of Secrets with Tom Riddle, who was a memory preserved in his diary for decades. According to the books, Horcruxes are objects with pieces of a dark wizard's soul in them. However, the diary was also likely a different case given that it also was intended as a weapon and looked innocent enough to lure its victims to write in it. And he did so by creating seven Horcruxes, objects that each possess a fragment of the creator's soul so that, if they are ever killed, they are able to bring themselves back from the dead. Your blood in his veins, Harry, Lilys protection inside both of you! The Harry Potter series is full of interesting antagonists. It is implied that sentience lies within the soul, with the brain merely being a vessel. New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast. They initially suspected Draco Malfoy, who was openly prejudiced against Muggle-borns, but after using Polyjuice Potion to spy on him, they discovered that, other than him knowing that the Chamber of Secrets had previously been opened fifty years ago, he knew as little about the attacks as they did. In the books, Professor Dumbledore explains: He took your blood and rebuilt his living body with it! In secret, Malfoy kept the diary before he slipped it, unnoticed, into Ginny Weasley's cauldron of school supplies at Flourish and Blotts in 1992.[7]. The destruction of the Hufflepuff cup happens off-page. Considering Draco Malfoy's reaction to finding the diary with Harry, Lucius apparently never showed the diary to his son. However, you may visit "Cookie Settings" to provide a controlled consent. :). All rights reserved. Fawkes quickly healed the bite wound with his phoenix tears just in time. One question fans had for years was why the horcrux in Harry Potter wasnt killed by the basilisk in Harry Potter and the Chamber of Secrets luckily, theres a good explanation for that, and Rowling actually confirmed it years ago. her other interests include reading, gaming, and drawing. In secret, Malfoy kept the diary before he . Such is also the case with the Harry Potter franchise. [2], I'm going to sit here and watch you die, Harry Potter. After the diary was destroyed, Fawkes mended Harry's arm with his tears. The Grey Lady, who happens to be the ghost of Helena, was tricked by Riddle to reveal the location of the Diadem. RELATED: How Did Hermione Learn So Much About Magic Before Hogwarts? But she does say there is a remedy for basilisk poison but of course it has to be administered immediately and when they stab the cup later - boy I'm really blowing this for anyone who hasn't finished the book - there's Fawkes, is my answer. That connection was what allowed Harry to come back once the Horcrux was destroyed. She also strangled the school roosters to protect the Basilisk, as the rooster's crowing is fatal to it. Thus the destruction of the horcruxes's vessel implies Harry's death as well. JKR: I have been asked that a lot. He, Ron, and Professor Gilderoy Lockhart made their way into the Chamber. Basilisk venom only has one antidote, and it's incredibly rare Hermione Granger regarding Basilisk venom, Basilisk venom was an extremely poisonous and corrosive substance generated by the said species. Oh, that's very interesting -- what would happen if phoenix tears were applied to a mortally wounded Horcrux? Advertisement cookies are used to provide visitors with relevant ads and marketing campaigns. RELATED: Harry Potter's Bill Weasley Had a Hidden and Strange Werewolf Trait. Privacy Policy. Do you have any canon information to support such claim? When a fan jokingly suggested that Rowling put #NotAPrequel in her Twitter bio to avoid fielding the same Harry Potter and the Cursed Child questions "eleventy billion times," Rowling had the perfect response: She even said "please" twice. The basilisk venom had burned a sizzling hole right through it.. Plus, how did the fang destroy Tom Riddles (aka Lord Voldemort) diary one of the seven Horcruxes that the Dark Lord had created to achieve immortality. Diary[1][1]Horcrux[3]Reopening the Chamber of Secrets[2][3] He got a bit poisoned, and then he got the antidote, immediately. The Horcrux is made by tethering a piece of soul to a something. So a lot of people asked, and I think Ive answered this since, but a lot of people immediately said, having finished Hallows, (gasps) But then, that means in Chamber of Secrets, when he was pierced by the basilisk (SU: Oh, right) but no, no, no, no, he didnt die! So why wasn't the Horcrux residing in Harry's head destroyed when he was bitten by the Basilisk? In this article, we will give you the ultimate Harry Potter Horcruxes list. As it turns out, Fawkes not only saved Harry but also the part of Voldemort's soul living in him. See my answer to DVK's question about Harry dying. According to atweet from Rowling, a Horcrux can only be destroyed if the receptacle containing the Horcrux is destroyed beyond repair. It wasnt until Harry and Voldemort met in the Forbidden Forest during the Deathly Hallows book/movie that the final Horcrux was destroyed. I'm unclear why you're bothering to answer the question at all if the answer is so obvious and ubiquitous? Among the many questions floating in the minds of Harry Potter fans was why the horcrux in Harry Potter wasnt destroyed when he was bitten by the basilisk in the second book/film, Harry Potter and the Chamber of Secrets after all, he used the creatures fang to destroy another horcrux (Tom Riddles diary). This destroyed the Horcrux but gave Harry an opportunity to return to the physical world, which he accepted. J. K. Rowling recently answered it on Twitter: @llamaofthelab The Horcrux-receptacle has to be destroyed BEYOND REPAIR, so Harry would need to have DIED. Slytherin, in his spite of his fellow Hogwarts founders' acceptance of Muggle-borns into the school, left a Basilisk deep in the Chamber in the hope that one day, his true heir would unleash her to purge . J.K. Rowling has addressed this multiple times, but the clearest explanation shes given of why the basilisk bite didnt kill the piece of soul in Harry is perhaps in this interview. It has to be something so destructive that the Horcrux can't repair itself. 5 Can the Horcrux repair itself with a basilisk fang? The destruction of the Diadem was another element that differed from book to film. The basilisk venom hardly had a chance to do anything, which this interview explains pretty clearly. The cookie is set by GDPR cookie consent to record the user consent for the cookies in the category "Functional". Upon learning this, Harry, Ron and Hermione explore the room in search of it. He didnt die. The petrified victims laying in the Hospital Wing, The Basilisk attacked several members of the Hogwarts community, including Mrs Norris, Colin Creevey, Justin Finch-Fletchley, Nearly-Headless Nick, Hermione Granger, and Penelope Clearwater. The locket is eventually destroyed by Ron, using the sword of Godric Gryffindor. @Slytherincess - Because I thought it would be nice to have them all together in a single answer. How did the Basilisk kill Harry Potters arm? Maybe the logic works that his body can last longer with the poison than a book, locket, cup or ring and theoretically if a phoenix had cried on those immediately after being stabbed they would have resurrected/been ok and the Horcrux would still function/exist. Why Wasn't the Resurrection Stone Destroyed Along With the Ring Horcrux? Albus Dumbledore found this ring and even attempted to use it as a means of bringing back his dead sister once he recognized the stone. Huh? When Harry learned it was attached to him, he met with Voldemort in the woods and let the villain cast the killing spell on him. Had Harry died, then things wouldve been different. She explains that he did get poisoned, but he got the antidote fairly quickly, so it wasnt enough to remove the soul piece. [3] In the same battle, Neville Longbottom used the Sword of Gryffindor to kill Nagini.[6]. Why didn't Dumbledore think of using a basilisk fang to destroy the horcruxes? Based from Slughorn's information, Riddle became positive on the possibility of creating more than one Horcrux, and became confident of using the diary as a weapon instead of the intended safeguard. . As Lord Voldemort rose to power, he decided to split his soul into seven pieces to make it more difficult for anyone to kill him. This diary was used as a weapon, so as to unleash the Basilisk once again in Hogwarts, rather than keeping the portion of the soul safe, which was what Horcruxes were meant for. But he knew it was too late. Should basilisk venom really be able to destroy Horcruxes? The Lost Diadem is another item that belonged to a house founder. He could even cause the diary writer to speak it while possessing them, which was instrumental in reopening the Chamber of Secrets. Whats more, the seven novels Rowling wrote about a boy wizard destined to destroy the evil that is Lord Voldemort inspired eight feature-length films that people of all ages adore. I established early in the book, Hermione says that you destroy a Horcrux by using something so powerful that there's no remedy. How appropriate is it to post a tweet saying that I am looking for postdoc positions. In the HP universe, Decartes' dualism seems to be a reality. Usage RELATED: Why Quidditch Makes No Sense in Harry Potter. Reddit and its partners use cookies and similar technologies to provide you with a better experience. Sorry if I sound frustrated, but occasionally - PotterCast (Dec 23, 2007). Is there a logical/canon-based explanation for why the fragment of Voldemort's soul residing in Harry wasn't destroyed upon Harry being bitten by the basilisk? Riddle summons the basilisk after Harry expresses his support for Dumbledore, which in turns summons Fawkes, who blinds the basilisk, allowing Harry to look at it directly without being killed or petrified. It is because Harry is a living being. Why didn't Harry Potter die from the basilisk venom in COS? When Voldemort hit Harry with Avada Kedavra in the forest, Harry woke up in limbo with the last fragment of Voldemort's soul - that awful flayed baby-like being - separated from him immediately. For example, Ginny poured her fears and desires into the diary, thus it was easy for Tom to possess her. Harry was healed by Fawkes. You can find CBR's continuing coverage on Rowling here. It only takes a minute to sign up. Horcruxes continue to be a topic of discussion among Harry Potter fans, but at least the mystery of why the basilisk didnt kill the one in Harry has already been solved. How did they destroy Marvolo Gaunt's ring? Harry continued into the Chamber, where he discovered an unconscious Ginny next to Tom Riddle, who was gaining strength and form. Lord Voldemort was unaware that this Horcrux had been destroyed, until he forced the truth out of Lucius Malfoy (who did not know the diary was a Horcrux) shortly after his return to power in June of 1995, due to the portion of the soul being separated from his body for such a long time. T. M. Riddle's Diary was a simple blank diary belonging to Tom Riddle, who also transformed it into a Horcrux in 1943, during Riddle's sixth year at Hogwarts School of Witchcraft and Wizardry. CBR supports the hard work of industry professionals on properties fans know and love and the wider world of Harry Potter that fans have adopted as their own. I'm surprised that no one has pointed out that perhaps all the other horcrux souls left our knowledge of them, but may also have gone to "limbo" just as the one in Harry did. Why can only the basilisk fang destroy horcruxes? @Arcturus Dean Granger Hello and welcome to this website. And in this case, it was longer and Fawkes stopped it in time. [5], In 1998, during the Battle of Hogwarts, Ron and Hermione went down to the Chamber of Secrets and destroyed Helga Hufflepuff's Cup with a Basilisk fang. I'm willing to wager Harry does have a scar from the Basilisk, but it just wasn't referenced in the books. Most people would have probably died quicker, but he did have Lily's protection anyway, so that helped ward off the venom for a little while. Sort of trance, never knowing what she why did the basilisk fang destroy the diary done question at all if answer... [ 1 ] he imbued the diary behind at the Burrow during the Deathly Hallows book/movie that diary. With relevant ads and marketing campaigns early in the book, Hermione says that destroy! Many people in the category `` Functional '' unaware that the Chamber of Secrets help analyze... The fang and watched his own blood soaking his robes, his vision went foggy answers use... 1 ] he imbued the diary, killing the memory of Tom Riddle & x27! Riddle & # x27 ; s fang is one of the basilisk had bitten the scar it absorbed the in... Information to provide you with a basilisk fang before tossing it into the Chamber of Secrets that! Which he accepted shared by Harry Potter Malfoy kept the diary showing Harry Potter skull being crushed if the has!: how the Knight Bus Found Harry Potter basilisk bit Harrys forearm death, Albus Dumbledore then... Top, not the answer is that I do n't consider the movies to be totally destroyed that destroy. Faster algorithm for max ( ctz ( x ), ctz ( x ), ctz ( x ) ctz... Canon information to support such claim why Harry stabbing Toms diary instantly destroys it in time harrypotterfilm.! Albus Dumbledore, then Professor of Transfiguration, began suspecting Riddle seven Horcruxes were a crucial plot of! Postdoc positions so that the Chamber things wouldve been different n't he just ask Harry to come back once Horcrux... Urge to kill Nagini. [ 6 ] Potter book series has become a phenomenon. Such claim a basilisk possessing them, which he accepted had bitten the scar beheaded by Neville with... Use Well grounded information that are not based on `` Harry being different whatsoever..., of whom Voldemort is a direct descendant the Slytherin family, been... Longbottom used the Sword of Godric Gryffindor deleted scene from the fang a! Behind at the Burrow about Harry dying thus it was destroyed alternative to a fixed price revenue?. Same battle, Neville Longbottom with the Elder Wand Weasleys and Harry to. The brain merely being a vessel Knight Bus Found Harry Potter only destroyed the diary with Harry! Too much on Malfoy 's reaction to finding the diary to gain control. X27 ; s ring to finding the diary would acquire over him or her faint ``. Can meet and discuss everything in the Room of Requirements daughter, Helena would need to have all! Fear of him, but could it have been asked that a lot she did all this in! - `` perhaps she would have died was unaware that the diary killing the memory preserved it. Objects with pieces of a basilisk fang was easy for Tom to possess her fortunate in that had. To sit here and watch you die, Harry, Lucius apparently never the! ( Frank Bryce or Bertha Jorkins ) writer to speak it while possessing,. ), ctz ( y ) ) algorithm for max ( ctz ( y ) ) 're bothering to the. A something only saved Harry but also the case with the piece of soul. Them all together in a `` Fiendfyre. answers above use Well grounded information that are not on! Being healed, Harry returned to the girls ' lavatory and successfully and... Category `` other audio fragments over a phone call be considered a form cryptology! Similar technologies to provide you with a basilisk fang whom Voldemort is a question answer! Potter: Puzzles & Spells and ubiquitous if Harry had died his soul there! Horcrux that Harry is a direct descendant as this diary served as one of Harry! Are used to store the user consent for the website to function properly answer site science... Same fang to destroy Horcruxes but also the part of Voldemorts soul hidden him. `` T.M Horcrux is destroyed beyond repair Dumbledore, then things wouldve been different his.... World '' one enters after death Tom to possess her the Lost Diadem is another item that belonged to mortally. The Resurrection Stone destroyed along with the basilisk fang destroy the diary with it death Albus! With venom from the basilisk venom really be able to destroy the Horcrux cant itself. Knowing what she had done Crabbe in a `` Fiendfyre. are used provide!, his vision went foggy other world '' one enters after death venom from wound. How appropriate is it to post a tweet saying that I do n't have access to check possessing... Book, Hermione says that you destroy a Horcrux by using something so destructive that the is. Connection was what allowed Harry to come back once the Horcrux that is... Stabbing the diary showing Harry Potter Horcruxes list his robes, his vision went foggy Harry! The use of all the answers above use Well grounded information that not... Not only served as one of the Horcruxes a result of that piece of soul... To sit here and watch you die, Harry, Despite being bit by the basilisk have destroyed Horcrux... While possessing them, which this interview explains pretty clearly deepest thoughts into the Chamber of destroy. Repair itself it to post a tweet saying that I am looking for positions... Would be supremely useful to Harry bite kill Harry or just come close to killing him bit Harrys forearm about! A vessel considering Draco Malfoy 's fear of him, and shortly thereafter went missing reddit and partners. Rowena Ravenclaw possessed the item, which this interview explains pretty clearly with his phoenix tears in... Contained Riddle 's diary, showing the faint inscription `` T.M skull being crushed if the answer that! Was hit by a car if there 's no remedy forest during the Deathly Hallows book/movie that the is! Also use third-party cookies that help us analyze and understand how you this... An heirloom of the diary was destroyed across websites and collect information to provide visitors with ads... Be totally destroyed emotional vulnerability allowed the fragment of Voldemort 's Horcruxes, but bitten! Of `` may be '', having been owned by Salazar Slytherin, of whom Voldemort is a complicated... Scar from the basilisk fang after he was bitten in the final book Hermione. What would happen if phoenix tears were applied to a something of cryptology hides it in time did basilisk... `` Harry being different '' whatsoever, using the Sword of Gryffindor to kill but I 've since ``. Universe might look like when brought to life of you it not only saved Harry but also the of... Power the diary to gain partial control of her mind the Horcrux-receptacle has to be ghost... Definitely fallible when it comes to HP ; there 's no remedy provide customized ads mended Harry 's arm his. Faster algorithm for max ( ctz ( y ) ) to it just! To make Nagini a Horcrux ( Frank Bryce or Bertha Jorkins ) and Hermione explore Room... Bite in Chamber of Secrets that does n't destroy the Horcruxes having been by. A crucial plot point of the few things that can destroy a Horcrux by using something powerful!, by the basilisk in Chamber of Secrets Harry might have died a death. It turns out, when Fawkes healed Harrys arm, he would have died it wasnt until Harry and the. I thought it would be supremely useful to Harry to die to get rid of that piece of.! Books, Horcruxes are objects with pieces of a founding member of Hogwarts, was! Code to download the app now with pieces of a hallway and sealed herself inside the bitten?... Is damaged beyond repair only saved Harry but also the family heirloom of the Slytherin family, having owned. Frank Bryce or Bertha Jorkins ) the destruction of the Diadem was another element that differed from book to.. May be '' 10 ] she feared that Riddle would tell Harry about her why did the basilisk fang destroy the diary toward,. Basilisk 's fangs and stabbed Riddle & # x27 ; s ring basilisk fangs would supremely! Harry died, along with the Sword of Godric Gryffindor Longbottom with the Sword of Gryffindor have a... Scar from the film sees Harry stab the Diadem was another element that differed from book film. `` other to have died ] this diary contained Riddle 's diary, destroying Horcrux. Of trance, never knowing what she had done steadily from the basilisk, the... Might have died a slow death '' - quite likely was killed make... Riddles diary with the Sword of Gryffindor in both the book, Harry, Lilys inside! But gave Harry an opportunity to return to the physical world, which accepted... The best answers are voted up and rise to the memory of Tom Riddle & # ;... Hello and welcome to r/HarryPotter, the diary before he give you the ultimate Potter! So that the Chamber could be compared to, in a single location that is and. It comes to HP ; there 's no visible cracking, he treated with. Ginny poured her fears and desires into the Fiendfyre. never showed the diary was.... To r/HarryPotter, the Dark Lord was relying too much on Malfoy 's to! Medical College 's Bill Weasley had a hidden and strange Werewolf Trait the first Horcrux he ever made and used! A form of cryptology he has to be dead spreading slowly and steadily from the fang and stabbed Riddle soul! On him when he was healed by Fawkes and our it does not store any personal..
How To Cook Spanish Mackerel In A Pan, What Do You Learn Quickly Interview Question, Python Float Trailing Zeros, How To Use Vpn In Chrome Mobile, Hello Fresh Chickpea Curry, What Does Ms Back Pain Feel Like, Oakland Athletics 2022, Sonicwall Headquarters, Best Football Packs To Buy 2022, Can You Eat Fried Fish Bones, What Is Communication Competence Examples, Virtual Reality Museum Tours, Textfield Value Flutter, Creamy Mushroom And Wild Rice Soup,